|The Canadian Patriot||June 13, 1992||Amherstburg, Ontario||-a-|
|Denny Kass||March 5, 1993||Warren, Ontario|
|Mickey Doyle||May 29, 1993||LaSalle, Ontario|
|Rock Stevens||July 4, 1993||Livonia, MI||-b-|
|Scott D'Amore||August 14, 1993||Noelville, Ontario||-c-|
|Jack Steel||May 6, 1994||North Bay, Ontario|
|Scott D"Amore ||May 7, 1994||Noelville, Ontario|
|Mickey Doyle ||June 17, 1994||Wallaceburg, Ontario|
|Scott D'Amore ||March 10, 1995||Oldcastle, Ontario|
|Bruiser Bedlam||April 21, 1995||LaSalle, Ontario|
|Scott D'Amore ||June 23, 1995||LaSalle, Ontario|
|Sabu||May 17, 2000||London, Ontario||-d-|
|Tommy Dreamer||March 7, 2001||Oldcastle, Ontario||-e-|
|Scott D'Amore ||April 18, 2001||Oldcastle, Ontario|
|Mikey Whipwreck||April 18, 2001||Oldcastle, Ontario|
|Johnny Swinger||November 27, 2001||Oldcastle, Ontario|
|The Brooklyn Brawler||January 15, 2003||Oldcastle, Ontario||-f-|
|Johnny Swinger ||January 15, 2003||Oldcastle, Ontario||-g-|
|D'Lo Brown||March 6, 2003||Oldcastle, Ontario|
|Shane Douglas||September 14, 2003||Belleville, MI||-h-|
|D'Lo Brown ||July 18, 2004||Belleville, MI||-i-|
|A-1||December 12, 2004||Belleville, MI|
|Bobby Roode||July 22, 2005||Oldcastle, Ontario|
|Abyss||September 15, 2005||Windsor, Ontario|
-a- Defeated Bobby Clancy in the finals of a tournament to become the first champion.
-b- Vacated when Stevens is stripped of the title on July 29, 1993
-c- Defeated Otis Apollo for the vacant title.
-d- Stripped on March 7, 2001
-e- Defeated Scott D'Amore and Rhino in a Three-Way match for the vacant title.
-f- Stripped on January 15, 2003.
-g- Title returned to Swinger.
-h- Vacated in 2004.
-i- Defeated Gangrel for the vacant title.