|Otis Apollo||June 23, 1995||LaSalle, Ontario||-a-|
|Terry Richards||August 16, 1996||LaSalle, Ontario||-b-|
|Professor Maxwell||November 24, 1996||Windsor, Ontario||-c-|
|Larry Brun||January 1997||Windsor, Ontario|
|Canadian Destroyer||February 1997||Windsor, Ontario|
|Bo Lewis||March 22, 1997||Windsor, Ontario|
|Gene Miller||March 29, 1997||Windsor, Ontario||-d-|
|The Brooklyn Brawler||April 3, 1998||LaSalle, Ontario||-e-|
|Chris Sabin||March 6, 2003||Oldcastle, Ontario||-f-|
|Alex Shelley||September 19, 2004||Windsor, Ontario|
|Chris Sabin ||January 21, 2005||Oldcastle, Ontario|
|Petey Williams||April 17, 2005||Belleville, MI|
|N8 Mattson||July 15, 2006||Windsor, Ontario|
-a- Defeated Max Anthony to become the first champion.
-b- Vacated on November 22, 1996.
-c- Defeated Larry Brun for the vacant title.
-d- Vacated on June 21, 1997.
-e- Defeated Bobby Clancy for the title. Title vacated after Brawler is stripped on March 6, 2003 for failing to appear.
-f- Defeated Franike Kazarian and Jerry Lynn in a Three-Way Dance for the vacant title.