|Mike Mizanin||December 1, 2005||McDonough, GA||-a-|
|Derrick Neikirk||December 22, 2005||McDonough, GA|
|Ryan O'Reilly||June 22, 2006||McDonough, GA|
|Bradley Jay||September 7, 2006||McDonough, GA|
|Vito||January 25, 2007||McDonough, GA|
|Bradley Jay ||February 22, 2007||McDonough, GA|
|Ryan O'Reilly ||March 1, 2007||McDonough, GA|
|Bradley Jay ||March 8, 2007||McDonough, GA||-b-|
|Austin Creed||July 12, 2007||Locust Grove, GA||-c-|
-a- Defeated Mike Knox in the final of a tournament to become the first champion.
-b- Title held up on March 15, 2007 after Jay and O'Reilly fight to a double countout. WWE ends its relationship with DSW on April 18, 2007, leaving the title vacant.
-c- Defeated Murder One in the finals of a tournament to win the vacant title.