|Harry Smith||June 26, 2007||Tampa, FL||-a-|
|Afa Jr.||October 16, 2007||New Port Richey, FL||-b-|
|TJ Wilson||December 1, 2007||New Port Richey, FL||-c-|
|Ted DiBiase Jr.||December 18, 2007||New Port Richey, FL|
|Heath Miller||January 19, 2008||New Port Richey, FL||-d-|
|Jake Hager||March 22, 2008||New Port Ritchey, FL||-e-|
-a- Wins a 21-man battle royal to become the first champion.
-b- Awarded when Smith was called up to wrestle on a RAW European tour.
-c- Wins title in a ladder match.
-d- Awarded title after DiBiase in injured and unabel to defend.
-e- Unified with FCW Florida Heavyweight Title and subsequently retired.