|Homicide||September 25, 2004||Tampa, FL||-a-|
|Bryan Danielson||January 14, 2006||Philadelphia, PA||-b-|
|Roderick Strong||November 10, 2006||Inverness, FL|
|Erick Stevens||December 30, 2007||New York, NY|
|Roderick Strong ||February 16, 2008||Crystal River, FL|
-a- Defeated CM Punk in the finals of a 16-man tournament to become the first champion.
-b- Defeated Homicide and Roderick Strong ina 3-Way dance to win the belt.