|Spyder||October 11, 2003||Parkersburg, WV||-a-|
|Dru Onyx||October 15, 2004||Winnipeg, Canada||-b-|
|Fergal Devitt||October 27, 2004||Cardiff, England|
|Dru Onyx ||October 30, 2004||Ashford, England|
|Fergall Devitt ||October 8, 2005||Nashville, TN|
|Karl Anderson||March 12, 2006||Santa Monica, CA|
|Alex Koslov||June 11, 2006||Santa Monica, CA|
|Justin White||July 9, 2006||Santa Monica, CA|
|Paul Tracey||August 27, 2006||Bray, Ireland|
|Dru Onyx ||October 26, 2007||St. Albans, VT|
-a- Defated Fergal Devitt to become the first champion. Not allowed to defend the title due to a controversial finish that was under review as well as multiple protests from NWA UK Hammerlock; stipped of the title on October 1, 2004.
-b- Defeated Will Phoenix for the vacant belt.