|Brent Albright||January 26, 2005||Louisville, KY||-a-|
|Deuce Shade||June 11, 2005||Louisville, KY||-b-|
|Ken Doane||June 22, 2005||Louisville, KY|
|CM Punk||November 5, 2005||Louisville, KY|
|Aaron Stevens||January 6, 2006||Louisville, KY||-c-|
|Seth Skyfire||March 8, 2006||Louisville, KY|
|Charles Evans||August 23, 2006||Louisville, KY|
|Devon Driscoll||October 11, 2006||Louisville, KY|
|Charles Evans ||November 1, 2006||Louisville, KY|
|Seth Skyfire ||November 15, 2006||Louisville, KY|
|Eddie Kraven||January 7, 2007||Louisville, KY||-d-|
|Boris Alexiev||January 24, 2007||Louisville, KY||-e-|
|Mike Kruel||February 7, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|Boris Alexiev ||March 14, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|Shawn Spears||March 17, 2007||Cincinnati, OH|
|Cody Runnels||July 6, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|Shawn Spears ||July 13, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|Ted "The Trailer" McNalier||September 19, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|Shawn Spears ||October 24, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|Colt Cabana||October 31, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|James Curtis||November 14, 2007||Louisville, KY|
|Jamin Olivencia||February 20, 2008||Louisville, KY|
|Joey Matthews||March 12, 2008||Louisville, KY|
|"Tubby" Tommy McNaler||April 16, 2008||Louisville, KY|
|JD Michaels||June 4, 2008||Louisville, KY|
-a- Defeats Seth Skyfire to become the first champion.
-b- Albright vacates the belt after winning the OVW Heavyweight Title. Shade defeats Ken Doane in a tournament final to win the belt.
-c- Match was originally a 3-way elimination match between Punk, Brent Albright, and Ken Doane. Doane was knocked out at ringside when he fell and hit the announce table. Stevens came to ringside and asked to replace him and was allowed to do so.
-d- Kraven's tag team partner, Mike Kruel, was also allowed to defend the belt under the Freebird rule.
-e- Alexiev defeats Mike Kruel.