|The Prophecy (Christopher Daniels and Donovan Morgan)||September 21, 2002||Philidelphia, PA||-a-|
|AJ Styles and The Amazing Red||March 15, 2003||Cambridge, MA||-b-|
|The Backseat Boyz (Johnny Kashmere and Trent Acid)||September 20, 2003||Philidelphia, PA||-c-|
|Special K (Dixie and Izzy)||October 16, 2003||Glen Burnie, MD|
|Jay and Mark Briscoe||November 1, 2003||Elizabeth, New Jersey|
|The Second City Saints (Colt Cabana and CM Punk)||April 24, 2004||Chicago, IL|
|The Prophecy (Dan Maff and B.J. Whitmer)||May 15, 2004||Lexington, MA||-d-|
|Jay and Mark Briscoe ||May 15, 2004||Lexington, MA||-d-|
|The Second City Saints (Colt Cabana and CM Punk)||May 15, 2004||Lexington, MA||-d-|
|The Rottweilers (Ricky Reyes and Rocky Romero)||August 7, 2004||Philidelphia, PA|
|Dan Maff and BJ Whitmer||February 19, 2005||Elizabeth, NJ||-e-|
|Jimmy Jacobs and BJ Whitmer||April 2, 2005||Asbury Park, NJ||-f-|
|The Carnage Crew (HC Loc and Devito)||July 9, 2005||New York City, NY|
|Jimmy Jacobs and BJ Whitmer ||July 22, 2005||Philidelphia, PA|
|Tony Mamaluke and Sal Rinauldi||October 1, 2005||New York City, NY|
|Austin Aries and Roderick Strong||December 18, 2005||Edison, NJ|
|The Kings of Wrestling (Claudio Castagnoli and Chris Hero)||September 16, 2006||New York City, NY|
|Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal||November 25, 2006||Edison, NJ|
|Jay and Mark Briscoe ||February 24, 2007||Chicago, IL|
|Naruki Doi and Shingo||March 3, 2007||Liverpool, England|
|Jay and Mark Briscoe ||March 30, 2007||Detroit, MI|
|The Age of the Fall (Tyler Black and Jimmy Jacobs)||December 30, 2007||New York City, NY|
|No Remorse Corps (Davey Richards and Rocky Romero)||January 28, 2008||Chicago Ridge, IL|
|Jay and Mark Briscoe ||April 12, 2008||Edison, NJ||-g-|
|The Age of the Fall (Tyler Black and Jimmy Jacobs) ||June 6, 2008||Hartford, CT||-h-|
|El Generico and Kevin Steen||September 19, 2008||Boston, MA|
-a- Defeat American Dragon and Michael Modest in the finals of a tournament to crown the first champions.
-b- Titles vacated on September 20, 2003 after The Amazing Red sustains a knee injury.
-c- Win a Tag Team Gauntlet Match, last eliminating Special K (Dizie and Izzy) to win vacant titles.
-d- All title defenses and changes took place during a Round Robin Tournament.
-e- Titles are vacated after Dan Maff retires from professional wrestling in March 2003.
-f- Defeat Jay Lethal and Samoa Joe to win vacant titles.
-g- Vacated on May 11, 2008 due to a write injury to Mark.
-h- Defeated El Generico and Kevin Steen in the finals of a one-night tournament to win the vacant titles.