|Ken Johnson||March 19, 1999||San Antonio, TX||-a-|
|Venom||October 16, 1999||San Antonio, TX||-b-|
|Tiger Steele||February 15, 2000||San Antonio, TX|
|Venom ||February 15, 2000||San Antonio, TX||-c-|
|Justin Credible||March 21, 2000||San Antonio, TX|
|Shawn Michales||March 21, 2000||San Antonio, TX||-d-|
|Shooter Schultz||April 18, 2000||San Antonio, TX||-e-|
|Charles Poindexter Anderson||June 17, 2000||San Antonio, TX|
|Sho Funaki||July 15, 2000||San Antoino, TX|
-a- Defeated Pete Lothario in the finals of a tournament to become the first champion.
-b- Venom was the champion at the beginning of the TWA "Total Impact" TV tapings.
-c- Awarded the title after Venom joins Steele's stable.
-d- Awarded title by Credible; vacated on April 4, 2000
-e- Defeated Venom in the finals of a tournament for the vacant title.